Independent Ireland TD, Ken O’Flynn, has called on an Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Simon Harris to publicly correct Fine Gael Senator Mike Kennelly after the Senator told the Seanad that credit union members should withdraw cash for their Christmas spend in the wake of the Wellington IT data breach, declaring that “cash is still king.”
Deputy O’Flynn said his constituency office had been fielding calls from worried and upset elderly people across Cork North Central and neighbouring constituencies.
“Many of them fear for small savings they have put aside to pay for their own funerals,” he said.
Deputy O’Flynn, who holds a QFA qualification, said he would never give such advice, and that comments like this from a Government Senator risk sparking a run on credit unions at a time when members’ money is safe.
“My office has been taking calls all day from frightened older people. Many of them have five or six thousand euro in the credit union. They call it their burial money,” he said. “It is what they have saved so they will not be a burden on their families when they die. Some might see that as a small amount. To them it means everything.”
“They were already worried about the breach. Then a Government Senator stood up in the Houses of the Oireachtas and told the public to take cash out of their credit union. Despite every assurance, they are now ringing me asking if their money is still there. That is the damage his words have done, and it is being felt in homes right across the country.”
“Senator Kennelly cannot have it both ways. In one breath he praised credit unions as the heart of our communities. In the next he handed out financial advice to the whole country that undermines confidence in those same credit unions. Even the suggestion of withdrawals, coming from the Government benches, can be enough to start a run on an institution. That is reckless and it is dangerous,” the Cork North Central TD said.
SENATOR KENNELLY URGED CAUTION
The Fine Gael Senator had said that he wanted to stress the need to warn the public about potential phone fraud in the wake of the hack which affected credit union data – saying “the cyberattack was done to take people down over the phone and scam them.”
He went on to urge people to withdraw cash if they want to buy something in the run-up to Christmas and to spend locally, while clarifying that members should avoid emptying their accounts to store cash at home.
“We are in the run up to Christmas and I urge people to attend to their credit union accounts and withdraw cash if they want to buy something,” he said.
“Cash is still king and that fact has become more evident,” he said. “I do not mean people should empty their accounts and store their cash in their homes, which may be unsafe
Deputy O’Flynn said that his words had an impact. “Nobody is arguing against cash. People are entitled to use it and I will always defend that. But there is a world of difference between defending cash and telling people, in the middle of a cyber attack, to go and take their money out.”
“I hold a qualification as a Qualified Financial Adviser. I would never give that advice, and no responsible adviser would. On what basis did the Senator decide he was in a position to tell the public what to do with their savings?” he said.
“Not that long ago the HSE was hit by a major cyber attack. Nobody told people to take the patients out of the hospitals. You deal with the attack, you protect the people affected and you keep the service running,” he added.
“So let me be clear to every older person worried tonight. Your money is safe. Members’ accounts and balances were not compromised in this breach, and every credit union is covered by the State’s Deposit Guarantee Scheme up to €100,000 per person.”
“The real danger is scammers using stolen details to target people, especially older people, over the phone. Never give your PIN, password or a one time code to anyone, even someone who says they are from your credit union. If in doubt, hang up and ring your credit union on a number you know.”
“Credit unions have been the backbone of this country for generations. The movement was founded by a north Cork woman, Nora Herlihy from Ballydesmond, and Ballyphehane Credit Union in Cork began in a church basement in 1960 with just 38 members. Volunteers have given their time ever since so that nobody is left behind. They did not cause this breach and they deserve to be defended, not undermined,” the Independent Ireland TD said.
“This breach happened in early October and members only found out this week. That happened on Simon Harris’s watch as Minister for Finance. He must explain why the public was kept in the dark for weeks, and he must correct his Senator’s comments today. If he stays silent, Fine Gael owns these remarks.”
“Senator Kennelly should withdraw his comments and apologise to every older person he has frightened and every credit union volunteer in the country,” he said.
SPOKE IN SEANAD ON WEDNESDAY
Senator Kennelly urged credit union members to withdraw cash when making purchases in the run-up to Christmas following an IT security incident affecting a service provider, declaring that “cash is still king.”
Speaking in the Seanad on Wednesday, Senator Mike Kennelly said that some account holders were “shocked and horrified” to discover this week that their credit union accounts had been affected.
“Credit unions are at the heart of communities but this morning some people were shocked and horrified to learn that their accounts had been attacked,” he said.
“While it is reassuring that no members’ funds, passwords or account balances were compromised, personal financial information has been accessed, including payee names, IBAN numbers, account numbers, addresses and payment references,” he said.
Kennelly noted that he is a credit union member himself and warned that scammers could use the exposed details to defraud people ahead of Christmas.
“I am a user of the credit union,” Kennelly said.
“My account is probably one of the accounts affected. I use my credit account to pay certain individuals, organisations, groups and clubs.
“Now scammers can contact the people affected because they have their account information and will scam them in the run up to Christmas out of possibly thousands of euro. I urge the House, the Garda and whoever is involved in tackling this to double down and check this serious breach.”
He raised concerns about the length of time between the breach taking place early last month and the public being notified, criticising the oversight of credit union accounts.
“My biggest concern is that this breach occurred early in October but the public were only made aware of it this morning,” he said.
“Departments have been aware of it.”
Kennelly also asked whether any scams had already taken place since the incident and stressed the need to warn the public about potential phone fraud.
“This cyberattack was done to take people down over the phone and scam them,” he continued.
He went on to urge people to withdraw cash if they want to buy something in the run-up to Christmas and to spend locally, while clarifying that members should avoid emptying their accounts to store cash at home.
“We are in the run up to Christmas and I urge people to attend to their credit union accounts and withdraw cash if they want to buy something,” he said.
“Cash is still king and that fact has become more evident,” he said.
“I do not mean people should empty their accounts and store their cash in their homes, which may be unsafe. I just want to dispel the dread that their money is gone and I want the cyberattack investigated.”
Kennelly reassured credit union members that their money remained safe and urged them not to let scammers win.