There would be “no change” to Ireland’s Triple Lock, among other policies, “unless the people first give their assent in a referendum,” then-Foreign Affairs Minister Brian Cowen promised voters ahead of the second Nice Treaty vote in 2002.
Speaking in the Dáil in June 2002, the Fianna Fáil Minister sought to reassure voters about Ireland’s “traditional policy of military neutrality” as the Government campaigned for a Yes vote to ratify the European Union treaty.
Ahead of the ballot, the Government had secured a pair of formal statements at an EU summit in Spain known as the Seville Declarations, consisting of an Irish National Declaration and a European Council Declaration intended to clarify Ireland’s neutrality under EU treaties.
Cowen told TDs that the National Declaration confirmed Ireland would not join a European army or a mutual defence commitment, and would retain its Triple Lock mechanism, which requires United Nations endorsement, a Government decision and Dáil approval before Irish Defence Forces can take part in overseas missions.
“As the Taoiseach said in the Dáil on Tuesday, the Government secured agreement at the Seville European Council on a National Declaration and a European Council Declaration which confirm that Ireland’s traditional policy of military neutrality is in full conformity with our obligations under existing EU treaties, including the Treaty of Nice,” Cowen said at the time.
“The National Declaration confirms that Ireland is not party to any mutual defence commitment, that we are not party to any plans for a so-called European army and that we will continue to take our sovereign decision, on a case-by-case basis, on whether the Defence Forces will participate in humanitarian or crisis management tasks undertaken by the EU, based on the triple lock guarantee of UN endorsement, Government decision and Dáil approval.”
He added: “The Government has said there will be no change to that situation unless the people first give their assent in a referendum.”
Cowen said the accompanying declaration from EU leaders confirmed that European treaties imposed no obligation on Ireland to abandon its neutrality, adding that the Seville Declarations would be formally attached to Ireland’s ratification papers and sent to the UN if voters approved the treaty.
“The Seville European Council Declaration confirms that there are no obligations on Ireland arising from the EU treaties which would oblige us to depart from our policy of military neutrality,” he said.
“That understanding is shared by our EU partners, including our fellow neutrals Austria, Finland and Sweden. If the people consent to Ireland ratifying the Treaty of Nice in a referendum to take place in the autumn, the Seville Declarations will be annexed to Ireland’s instrument of ratification and forwarded to the United Nations.”
Cowen’s Dáil remarks came a year after Irish voters had turned down the Treaty of Nice in an initial referendum in June 2001, when 53.87% opposed the measure against 46.13% in favour.
Four months after the Seville Declarations, voters overturned that result in a second referendum in October 2002. On a turnout of 49.47%, the electorate backed the Twenty-sixth Amendment of the Constitution, clearing the way for ratification, by 62.89% (906,317 votes) to 37.11% (534,887 votes).
Notably, Micheál Martin was also a member of that 2002 Government, serving as Health and Children Minister at the time.
Now, the Government is pushing ahead with new laws that would strip out the need for UN endorsement.
Passed by TDs in an initial 79-71 vote last month, the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026 is continuing its passage through the Oireachtas and is slated to become law before year’s end.