To be fair to the Shinners, they are not the only party whose members have wound themselves up in knots in trying to answer the fairly simple and straightforward question as to what a woman is – a question which has always had an obvious answer until the advent of the current woke madness which, much like something else said by a certain famous Shinner, hasn’t gone away, you know.
The reason the pretence and the compelled speech accompanying it hasn’t receded, isn’t just because Sinn Féin had embraced an extreme trans agenda, but because almost all of the political parties did, with the exceptions of the bastions of sanity in Independent Ireland and Aontú and a handful of sensible and courageous Independents like Mattie McGrath and Carol Nolan.
So before we get to the frankly hilarious revelation that Mary-Lou’s party went to the bother of issuing written instructions to the party faithful on how to define ‘woman’, its worth reminding ourselves that until very recently such a missive would likely have met with nodding approval from the other towering intellects in Leinster House.
The Gender Recognition Act saying you can be either a man or woman was wholeheartedly supported by Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael when it was proposed by then Minister Joan Burton of Labour. And they all said nothing while school books were rewritten to tell children that they could be boys or girls or neither or both.
When psychotic maniac and sex offender Barbie Kardashian (who is a biological male born Gabrielle Alejandro Gentile) was being described as a woman and placed amongst vulnerable females in the prison population, Fine Gael’s Leo Varadkar stumbled over his response to Ben Scallan because it was then verboten across the political spectrum to dispute the frankly insane notion that a violent hairy biological male with a penis could insist that everyone recognise him as a woman.
That situation hasn’t changed by the way: the likes of Barbie will still be placed in women’s prisons because they say they are female.
Then we had the same cross-party support, with the above-mentioned exceptions, for taking the reference to mother out of Bunreacht na hÉireann which the electorate rejected with a thumping great majority. Yet just earlier this year, Micheál Martin crossly told Ben Scallan that, yes, children could be transgender and he didn’t want imported culture wars here, by which he likely meant anyone who disagreed should not bother making their views known.
So the madness has been contagious – and harmful. But Sinn Féin were also caught out on several instances publicly, such as when one of their leading lights, Eoin O’Broin TD, acted like a rabbit caught in the headlights when asked “what is a women”, waffling about gender being a social construct.
They stumbled on, like directionless sheep in a storm, with Sinn Féin TD, David Cullinane at first tweeting that the Scottish Supreme Court ruling confirming that the definition of woman is based on biological sex, as a “common sense judgement”, and then deleting the entirely sensibkle post and replacing it with a contrite apology, which was definitely not written by HQ at all, apologising for “the hurt and offence” that he had “caused to the Trans community”.
Back in the heady days of Woke.1, we had Sinn Féin Senator Fintan Warfield boldly claiming that Sinn Féin in Government would allow children under the age of 16 to take their parents to court in order to change their legal gender without the parents consent – and more recently Sinn Féin have been insistent on supporting ‘gender affirming care’ for adults, and been very reluctant to take a definitive position on stopping the practice of giving puberty blockers to children who may have gender dysphoria.
But the winds of change are blowing across the political divide and clearly the Shinners thought they’d better get their act in order – and they are, after all, a political party whose internal controls are renowned, even infamous.
And lo, on the Daily Mail today appeared the front page news that “internal documents prepared for members of Sinn Féin’s national executive (Ard Chomhairle) – [and] obtained by the Mail – show the party’s elected representatives will be advised that a ‘woman’ is defined as an ‘adult female’ as part of a new unpublished policy on gender identity.”
It’d all rather hilarious really: grown adults sitting down and writing the equivalent of “the rain is wet” as an unpublished policy so that people who are actually elected as legislators can have this kind of clarity. The world a sometimes seems very mad, or very stupid or both. It’s embarrassing that a political party, with all the issues troubling the world needs to issue this clarification to its members.
Speaking on Newstalk today, Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire of Sinn Féin told told Anton Savage that while this was a “complex issue” (its not really Donnchadh) the party’s newly stated view was “how most people would see it”. That’s the key phrase really, isn’t it? Sinn Féin realise they have lost the room on this one. God forbid they – or Fianna Fáil or Fine Gael – would take a principled stand on anything.
This admittance is only the most fundamental of acknowledgments that much of what is described as gender ideology is half-baked lunacy – but the sort of lunacy that is far from harmless, and intrudes not only on women’s privacy but their safety. And Laoghaire pointed out that the party’s definition of woman includes biological women and “those born male who identify as women”.
The grip that this ideology has on our education system, our legal system, our healthcare and much more, must be unwound. That’s a message not just for Sinn Féin, but for government.