Tánaiste Simon Harris has confirmed that the State hands out Help to Buy payments of up to €35,000 of taxpayers’ money “without once checking whether the person receiving it has any right to remain in Ireland”.
That’s the criticism being made by Independent Ireland TD, Ken O’Flynn, who says that the failure to carry out such checks “is an insult to every taxpayer in this country”.
And he said that when he asked how many Help to Buy payments have been recovered from people who left the property after losing or being refused immigration permission, and the amounts involved. “No figures were provided,” the Cork North Central TD said.
In July, internal departmental correspondence obtained by Gript revealed that at least 35% of Help to Buy (HTB) applicants were foreign-born. Thomas O’Reilly also reported that mortgage industry experts warned of organised abuse of the government-backed scheme.
According to the figures prepared by Revenue officials, and obtained by Gript, only 65% of Help to Buy applicants are Irish, with the figures derived courtesy of Department of Social Protection data.
The documentation released to Gript showed one civil servant remarking to colleagues about how easy the nationality figures are to obtain.
Indians (13%), Polish (3%) and Brazilian (2%) made up the three leading nationalities after Irish citizens as Revenue recently commenced a clampdown on fraudulent activity within the scheme around non-nationals claiming the first-time buyer scheme while holding property abroad.
Replying to seven parliamentary questions from Deputy O’Flynn, the Tánaiste and Minister for Finance, Simon Harris, has now confirmed to the Cork TD that nationality, immigration status and international protection status are not eligibility considerations.
The Minister’s reply states: “Nationality, immigration status and international protection status are not eligibility considerations. Revenue advise that such data is not collected or used as part of the HTB application process or the wider administration of the scheme.”
Deputy O’Flynn described what was happening as a “scandal hiding in plain sight”.
Help to Buy is a tax refund scheme for first time buyers of new homes valued at up to €500,000. The payment is the lowest of €35,000 (from 7 October 2026), 10 per cent of the purchase price, or the income tax and DIRT paid in Ireland over the previous four years.
According to the Minister, the scheme had supported over 70,000 individuals or couples as of 30 September 2026.
“Being in the international protection process does not rule a person out. Revenue does not collect the information, does not check it, and has no way of knowing,” Deputy O’Flynn said.
“This is a scandal hiding in plain sight,” he continued. “The Government is handing out up to €35,000 a time with its eyes shut. Over 70,000 payments, the maximum raised only last month, and not one question asked about whether the person has any right to be here for the five years the scheme requires.”
“Simon Harris tells me there is a clawback. Let’s be honest about what that clawback is. It is an honour system.
“The money only comes back if the person writes to Revenue and volunteers to hand it back. Someone who has been refused permission and left the country is not going to do that, and the Minister knows it,” he said.
“When I asked him how much has been recovered in those cases, he had nothing. Not a figure. Not an estimate. Nothing. You cannot recover what you refuse to track.”
Young couples who were born here, who have worked here and paid tax here their whole lives, are crucified with conditions to get a mortgage. Every payslip, every bank statement, every penny checked.
“Yet the State will not do the single most basic check on the people it is paying. That is an insult to every taxpayer in this country,” the Cork North Central Deputy said.
“This Government has a habit of not wanting to know. If you never collect the data, you can never be blamed for what it shows. That is not good government. It is wilful blindness with public money.
“I want three things, and I want them now. No Help to Buy payment without proof of a right to reside here for the full five years. Revenue and the Department of Justice sharing information the moment a permission is refused or ends. And full publication of how much has been clawed back, how much is outstanding, and how much has simply been lost.
“The Tánaiste can fix this or he can keep defending it. Either way, I will not let it go,” he added.
Deputy O’Flynn has tabled further questions on how many clawback cases Revenue has actually found itself, how much remains unpaid, and how much has been written off.