If there’s one thing we’ve learned from this pandemic, it’s that many ideas initially written off as “conspiracy theories” were actually just spoilers.
Now, in 2022, Europe is facing growing calls from governments and health authorities for legal vaccine mandates.
Recently EU President Ursula Von Der Leyen called for the bloc to move towards such mandates.
EU must consider mandatory Covid jabs, says Von der Leyen https://t.co/DUJXF4G2I1
— Guardian Weekly (@guardianweekly) December 1, 2021
Since then, numerous European countries have either adopted the policy or suggested it, including Austria, Greece, Germany, Italy, France and much more.
This week, both NPHET and NIAC announced they were considering mandatory vaccinations in Ireland.
NPHET to discuss mandatory vaccination following Department of Health legal paper https://t.co/H3bIvXeXZ6
— TheJournal.ie (@thejournal_ie) January 10, 2022
Mandatory vaccination could be ‘necessary for the overall good’ NIAC chair says https://t.co/iURSQHtE55
— Irish Examiner (@irishexaminer) January 10, 2022
With this in mind, let’s take a look at what certain media outlets said about jab mandates at the start of the pandemic.
In February of 2020, Canadian news outlet VICE published an article entitled “Anti-Vaxxers Are Terrified the Government Will ‘Enforce’ a Vaccine for Coronavirus.”
The piece reads:
“This is a common theme in the anti-vax world, and conspiracy theorist communities more broadly…” the author wrote.
She went on to describe how “sources of anti-vaccine misinformation on social media” which share “rumors and false speculation virtually nonstop” had been posting their concerns about “forced” or “mandatory” vaccination.
Now, bear in mind, I don’t know the people she’s talking about and I’m not acquainted with their beliefs. I’m not anti-vaxx myself, and I’m sure many of these types of pages share some fairly wacky stuff that I wouldn’t agree with.
But this precise prediction – that Covid-19 has led to mandatory vaccination – was correct. More importantly, media outlets like VICE were wrong. Whatever else these “anti-vaxxers” believe, they were right about that point. And so, will the author of the piece retract their comment and apologise?
Similarly, German outlet DW published a piece in May 2020 entitled “In Germany, vaccine fears spark conspiracy theories.”
Increasing numbers of Germans are turning out to protest the country's coronavirus measures. Among them are many with a strong suspicion of vaccines – even though inoculation against #COVID19 is far from a reality.https://t.co/EWwI5rCsRS
— DW Politics (@dw_politics) May 13, 2020
The piece quotes Jan Rathje, who DW describes as “an expert on anti-Semitism and conspiracy theories.”
According to Rathje:
The article continues with a tone that seems to imply that those who believe vaccines will be compulsory are being irrational, or that they have been taken in by misinformation.
In September of 2020, the BBC described an anti-lockdown protest which took place in the UK as being:
Conspiracy theories about coronavirus and QAnon are increasingly overlapping. https://t.co/lmuCUAzRWK
— BBC Future (@BBC_Future) September 3, 2020
There are more examples, of course – this list is by no means exhaustive.
The point here is less to rush to the defence of mad “conspiracy theories,” or to say that they have merit. There’s obviously a lot of nutty stuff out there, and not all of it is going to be credible. In fact, much of it clearly won’t be.
It’s more to say that the media, generally speaking, don’t always know what they’re talking about when it comes to the issues of “misinformation” or “fake news.”
There’s a list as long as your arm of things which the media once deemed deranged, tinfoil hat lunacy, and which today is unquestionable fact and established orthodoxy.
From vaccine mandates, to the Wuhan lab leak theory, to the efficacy of masks, media outlets have not only changed their tune on numerous vital issues, but they have done complete and utter reversals of their previous positions – all while expecting us not to notice or hold them accountable for any of it.
My point is not that we should be putting more stock in conspiracy theories – but perhaps we should be putting less stock in the mainstream media.