The worst image from the Dublin violence is not on most of the front pages

Amongst the thousands of videos uploaded on social media yesterday was one which briefly appeared of panic-stricken and distressed people around the primary school in Parnell Square where three children, and a woman who tried to protect them, had been stabbed by a man wielding a knife.

I can’t imagine the terror of that moment: of thinking that your child, who you had left safe and sound into school that morning, could now be lying bleeding on the ground calling out for you.

This has never happened before in Ireland, never. Small children coming out of school into the sunshine have never been subjected to a random, frenzied, knife attacks. Much like the Ashling Murphy murder, it doesn’t feel real: this further slippage into a society which seems less safe by the day.

Yesterday, two women from a nearby créche which provides after school services went to collect children from Gaelscoil Choláiste Mhuire on Parnell Square East. They were to walk with them the few hundred feet between the school and créche in the busy north inner city as they always do. It was just an ordinary day.

As they came out the door, these 5 and 6 year old children, they were suddenly and violently attacked by a man unknown to them, who starting slashing towards their faces, their necks, their little bodies, with a long knife – maybe ten inches long, one witness said.

Three children, two little girls and one little boy, were stabbed. One little girl, aged 5, was badly wounded and remains in a critical condition at Temple Street Children’s Hospital.

One of the women, who desperately threw herself between the attacker and the children, was also stabbed several times. She “defended those children with all her strength” one report said, and she is currently in a serious condition.

If it wasn’t for her heroism, and the incredible bravery of a passing Brazilian delivery worker, followed by the courage of others who stopped and restrained the knifeman, many more might have been injured or killed.

As it was, the medics who rushed from the Rotunda and from ambulances were met with the screams of hysterical, petrified, children who had been stabbed and terrified as no child should ever be.

It is unimaginable, horrifying, sickening. If this is our much-vaunted change, we are better without it.

This morning, the papers were full of angry headlines and vivid, stark, blown-up photos, but their focus had shifted, away from the stabbed children and onto the riots that followed.

As my colleagues, Fatima and Noble will testify, last night Dublin city centre was aflame in appalling, unprecedented scenes. A Luas train was burnt out, as were 3 Dublin Buses. Garda cars and Gardaí were attacked. Shops were looted.

It felt as if a powder keg had been lit, though in truth much of the rioting and looting that followed the stabbings were opportunistic.

The anger now being seen across middle-Ireland at the fear that is being created by these knife attacks was not driving the teenagers smashing windows last night. At the risk of sounding like a bleeding-heart lefty, that is an expression of the disconnect that has been festering amongst disadvantaged young men for a long time.

But the media, like the government and the Oppositon, were eager to change the conversation, and Dublin city centre being set on fire gave them perfect cover to do so. So the usual nonsense about  the ‘far-right’ started immediately, and the front pages are full of those photographs this morning.

But as spectacularly awful and vivid as those pictures are, with flames leaping from the page, that is not the image that I can’t shake all morning.

Instead I’m thinking of the haunting photograph of a pretty little pink schoolbag belonging to one of the little girls, lying on the ground next to paramedics who are working to save a child.

It’s a Skye Paw Patrol schoolbag. As parents of small children will know, Paw Patrol is the business, the delight and distraction of small children with its clever rhymes and songs, and its gorgeous puppies.

One of the puppies is Skye, and her big soft eyes, and floppy ears decorating the front pocket of the little pink schoolbag are a reminder of the innocence and joy of childhood.

That Skye Paw Patrol schoolbag doesn’t belong in a scene with stabbed children and frenzied attackers and paramedics and frantic parents. The incongruity is horrendous. But, in truth, nothing belongs in that scene. It should never have happened.

The media might want to move on to burning cars and condemnations but this is the dreadful scene I keep returning to. Children going to school clutching their Paw Patrol schoolbags in their little hands and ending up knifed on the ground or traumatised for life.

As a friend from the area said to me today, the attack took place in a part of the city which people in authority have long neglected. Those with power and influence never really give much thought to the problems of families in the inner city, unless they want to call them names for having the effrontery to protest peacefully in places like East Wall when migrant centres are dumped on already struggling communities.

You might have noticed that the carefully couched, politically correct language that apply in general debate didn’t apply then. It was perfectly fine to call people ‘knackers’ or ‘scumbags’ when they objected to hundreds of men being brought to live in their areas without consultation.

Its fine to punch down on your own while virtue-signalling about tolerance, when you’re a flag bearer for the new, shiny, progressive Ireland where children are stabbed leaving school.

Yes, the rioting was awful and destructive, and should never have happened. But that’s not the primary story from the past 24 hours. It’s only a week since Ashling Murphy’s heartbroken boyfriend, Ryan Casey, in a powerful appeal as part of his witness statement, said that Ireland no longer felt safe anymore. The media did their best to censor him.

Now a 5-year old girl lies in a critical condition in Temple Street hospital. Our thoughts and prayers are with her. That’s where our attention should be too.

Share mdi-share-variant mdi-twitter mdi-facebook mdi-whatsapp mdi-telegram mdi-linkedin mdi-email mdi-printer mdi-chevron-left Prev Next mdi-chevron-right Related Comments Members can comment by signing in to their account. Non-members can register to comment for free here.
Subscribe
Notify of

52 Comments
Most Voted
Newest Oldest
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Eamonn Dowling
5 months ago

Niamh , this is so well written and well observed. The poignancy would bring tears from a stone. Thank you for drawing the focus to where it should be.

Ar87
5 months ago

I knew as soon as the rioting started the media would place it’s focus on that rather than the more important matter of the children who were stabbed.

Unfortunately, the riots were the response of those who are not the brightest to a horrible incident. Burning a bus and the Luas is a ludicrous way to release your anger about anything.

So the way to prevent a repeat of the riot is for those who are in favour of mass immigration into Ireland to start listening to those people who are opposed to it. Well be waiting for them to grow up and stop calling people ‘far right’ for having a perfectly reasonable opinion. If they don’t engage in debate with smart people then those who are not the brightest will riot again in the future

Anne Donnellan
5 months ago
Reply to  Ar87

Vote no confudence in this appalling g9vernnent and stop WHO treaty

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Anne Donnellan

fine gael and FF have destroyed this country its in a sorry state

Seamus Molloy
5 months ago

Brilliant article Niamh, for my sins I listened to Claire Byrne this morning and all 2 hours were about burning buses and the scumbags running amok. Very little about the stabbing of 3 chidren and their teacher in the middle of our capital city in broad daylight. It’s disgraceful how the MSM try to twist peoples focus but it isn’t working.

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  Seamus Molloy

Every time they do this “far right” crap more and more people look at them and say Liars.

Ar87
5 months ago
Reply to  Seamus Molloy

Was the same on pat Kenny on newstalk

Quite disturbing actually that such little focus was on the little girls. It was like black people who ‘felt’ unsafe were of greater concern to the program producers.

Anne Donnellan
5 months ago
Reply to  Seamus Molloy

Covid Care shuld have departed with Tubs

James Doyle
5 months ago

It only took a spark to ignite the fire. The political classes gave them an excuse
by their 0pen door mass unvetted no health checks migration policy. It will all end in tears.

Ben Wheeler
5 months ago
Reply to  James Doyle

The attacker was vetted and had been on the country years, but they doesnt fit your agenda

ar87
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Sounds like the vetting job may not have been the most thorough

Tom Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Since when has anybody coming into this country been properly vetted? I smell Communist propaganda.

Eamonn Dowling
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Who has? What is his name?

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

He was refused asylum and issued with a deportation order which he dodged.
Over the last two months a man was stabbed in the back while standing outside the terminal by one of our unwanted guests. Two weeks ago another unwanted guest of ours went in to the GPO and started trying to attack people with a large knife while screaming Allah Akbar. He was disarmed by members of the public. The RTE website ran the story for half an hour untill they realised that the attacker was Muslim and then took it down. The story was buried by the media. Yesterday’s horrific stabbing attack was carried out about 400 yards from the GPO. The murder of two men in Sligo was carried out by a Muslim also. This guy was living off and housed by the state despite having 357000 euro in his possession that was found by the Guards when they searched the home the state provided him with. The fiance of Miss Murphy made a victim impact statement last week questioning how that piece of filth who murdered her was living off the state for the last ten years in a five bedroom house provided by the Irish tax payers. This part of the victim impact statement was no covered by RTE or the other media. Anyone can see a horrific pattern here. Yet Varadkat and RTE are back on their “far right” bandwagon.
Please tell me Mr. Ben Whelan what agenda are we trying to fit the facts to ?.

Claire Varnion
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Yes, it does. Some (many) people just hate our western civilization ,whether that fits YOUR agenda or not.

David Walsh
5 months ago

How can ordinary citizens show their disgust at what is going on? One way would be to oppose the Hate Speech bill which will limit our  freedom to even comment on incidents such as these where the pretext that the comment is “hateful” will be used to shut down commentary.
A protest meeting against the Hate Speech bill needs to be organised.

Anne Donnellan
5 months ago
Reply to  David Walsh

Lobby tds ad senatirs No Confidence in mc^ ntee. Without delay. First thing next week in both houses of oireachtas and STOP WO TREATY

Enda
5 months ago

So well written Niamh

BorisPastaBuck
5 months ago

Very well expressed article. Gript readers will probably be aware the President has opined on yesterday’s events. His statement refers to “groups with an agenda that attacks the principle of social inclusion”. Undeniably, we have seen individuals – probably facilitated by the use of social media – seeking to sow discord (certainly to create mayhem and engage in thievery and wanton destruction of property and, not least of all, injure Gardai). However I – for one – would be most interested if the President – once the “heat” has gone out of the immediate situation – could enlighten the Nation as to his thoughts on the very sinister development of Muslim preachers recently “being caught on camera” (in certain UK mosques) praying to Allah that all Jewish people be killed (plus a few “Infidels” into the bargain). The “doctrinal basis” of these utterances lies in certain passages in a particular book (N.B. I’m not implying any Imman or preacher here in Ireland teaches this extreme stuff) – no doubt, the President would unequivocally condemn the actions of these preachers – but “where’s the joined up reasoning” – there’s abundant evidence that many peoples from the Middle East and North Africa take – as their starting point – ideas completely antithetical to the President’s “principle of social inclusion” – does the President seriously believe that once such persons step down from a plane at Dublin Airport, the “principle of social inclusion” becomes their one and only guide as to behaviour ???

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  BorisPastaBuck

Don’t expect anything sensible to come out of the mouth of the world’s most expensive left wing leprechaun.

Dave Wall
5 months ago

Well said Niamh, Dubliners have always been treated like scum by the people who run Ireland. The young men who live in these parts of the city know it, feel it and live it. It’s the same for people who come from the big council estates, they don’t like smarmy gits like Varadkar or Saint Michael preaching to them, the more name calling they do just adds to the alienation. They have shifted the focus away from the spark for all this which they are ultimately responsible for just as they were responsible for Aisling Murphy. They should all resign immediately. What Varadkar and Martin will never accept is that their policies created this problem.

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Dave Wall

especially when those preaching at them are actually corrupt to the core

Claire Varnion
5 months ago

Look at what is going on in France. A 16-year old was killed in Crepol, France last Sunday, 10 injured, by muslims again. And before him, Lola, the Bataclan, Nice , etc etc … Good luck my Irish friends.

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Claire Varnion

c’est absolument horrible

Paula
5 months ago

Thank you Niamh you put my constant thought into words.

Stephen
5 months ago

You might mention that a Brazilian man helped stop the attack.

thomas
5 months ago
Reply to  Stephen

That has it’s own headline elswhere in the site, and I think the gript editor acknowldeged the fact early yesterday

Anne Donnellan
5 months ago
Reply to  thomas

Yes, generously

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Anne Donnellan

not to mention the Irishman Warren who was ignored by mass media and the Irish people have donated over 300k to the Brazilian man. why does he need to be given such a sum ?

Edward Fitzgerald
5 months ago

Thank god for the actions of a brave Brazilian immigrant. Let’s hope he is the person we remember most from this awful moment in our country’s history.

Ar87
5 months ago

You’re supposed to remember the children who were stabbed the most from this awful moment in our country’s history….

Robbie Elliott
5 months ago

Well I’m sure everything will work out well for the kids when drag queen story time pays them a visit.

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Robbie Elliott

jesus was wearing a tunic dress and read stories to children

Ben Wheeler
5 months ago

Fair play Niamh, some incredible mental gymnastics to absolve the poor widdle scumbags wreaking havoc in the city at the expense of the ordinary people, all in the aid of furthering your racist agenda. Gold star, you will be writing for the Irish Light in no time

ar87
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Could you give me your definition of rascism because I’m suspecting it is very very broad

Ben Wheeler
5 months ago
Reply to  ar87

It includes anyone whose belief system can be summed up with the phrase Ireland for the Irish.

ar87
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

o Good lord what a pathetic response

Rascism is the hatred of those from another racial group and often involves the belief that one race is inferior to another. Opposition to Mass Migration is not rascism. It never was rascism. It is a ludicrous re-definition of the meaning of the term to say rascism is people who says ‘Ireland is for the Irish’, and presumably ‘Sweden is for the Swedes’ or ‘France is for the French’.
What that is an attack of the very concept of a nation. This belief that any sense of patriotism or sense of nationalism is a form of rascism is utter nonsense.

thomas
5 months ago
Reply to  ar87

Yep by Ben’s reasoning his own grannies, great grannies, etc ad infinitum were also racists, as were all the nations who fought actual 20th c racism/fascism.

ar87
5 months ago
Reply to  thomas

Indeed. All past generations of Irish people who campaigned and fought for and many sacrificed their lives for our national independence from the British empire – and would certainly been comfortable with a phrase like ‘Ireland for the Irish’ = well turns out they were just a bunch of rascists after all – no different to the Nazis i Guess.

It was the belief that the southern states of the USA were behaving in an un-American way, that they were violating the American consitution with their jim crows laws that motivated so many white Americans to support the black civil rights campaigners in the 50s and 60s. But as they were nationalists they were still rascists.

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  thomas

Everyone is out of step except poor Ben. He alone knows the truth. May God protect us from the tyrant of ignorance.

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

That’s me. Ireland is the national home of the Irish race.

Claire Varnion
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Really? Indeed it is very weird to want a country to belong to its citizens. Do you think Algerian are racists because they (rightly so) think their country is for Algerians?

Seán O Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Claire Varnion

not to mention the overwhelmingly anti democracy, anti western that prevail across the MENA region. most would call THAT fascism or far right, as I do

Anne Donnellan
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Not racism patriotsm and common sense

David Walsh
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Do you believe that the people who have been protesting all across the country at more migrant centres being imposed on their communities are all racists?

Tom Sullivan
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Ben is a Commie troll. Ignore him.

Dave Wall
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

More middleclass drivel

BorisPastaBuck
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Is “Gript” really the “most comfortable place” for you, Ben Wheeler ? I’m a firm believer in freedom of expression (except – see my own comment above – when it comes to incitement to violence – incidentally, we can all help you to locate the videos of those vile utterances coming from the mouths of Muslim preachers in the UK, if you have any problem finding them). So on the basis of “freedom of expression” – whilst I can’t take serious objection to “your right to offend” Ms. Ui Bhriain – you can understand the “general run” of Gript readers is going to start associating the name “Ben Wheeler” with somebody who usually immerses himself in the pages of the Irish Times or the Irish Independent – and really hasn’t the time of the day for most of the “Gript” readership !

thomas
5 months ago
Reply to  BorisPastaBuck

There should be no problem with someone arguing his piece, even if it’s the opposite of the position of other commentators or the articles/comment pieces themselves, but he is, as others have pointed out, simply a troll. The odd thing is, though, that while other trolls would recognise their verbal spanners as mere deliberate attempts at verbal gremlin-work, his own attempts at heckling here seem to accurately reflect the actual, irrational workings of a disordered brain.

Eamonn Dowling
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

That’s a lot of hate speech there in one short comment Ben.

James Gough
5 months ago
Reply to  Eamonn Dowling

It very likely is also true

Claire Varnion
5 months ago
Reply to  Ben Wheeler

Ah ah ah! Everybody can understand WHO IS racist : the aggressor who blindly attacks people because they are Christian westerners.

Would you support a decision by Ireland to copy the UK's "Rwanda Plan", under which asylum seekers are sent to the safe - but third world - African country instead of being allowed to remain here?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...