Rape culture. Trans rights. Climate Justice. Free Palestine. Free contraception. Pride Month. Rainbow flags. Carbon Credits. Migrants rights. Brexit Britain. Misinformation. Hate speech. Homophobia. Biphobia. Transphobia. PhobiaPhobia. You are drinking too much. You are smoking too much. Maybe we should legalise drugs. You are driving too much. Electric cars now. You are using too much electricity. You are flying too much. You are eating too much. You are too fat. Body shaming. You are sitting down too much. You are racist. You are an anti vaxxer. You are endangering others. You are ruining the planet.
To live in Ireland these days is to endure that nonsense daily. If it were simply from a small cohort of online activists, that would be one thing. It’s an entirely different matter when the Irish Government basically has no other message beyond “you people need stop ruining the world and be better”
This tone permeates everything, up to and including Covid 19. There, as everywhere else in Irish life, the Government is firmly of the view that the people need to be better. No dancing. No singing. Masks when sitting. You lost the run of yourselves at Christmas. You’re not vaxxed. You’re not careful. On and on and on and on it goes – endless preaching, never any responsibility taken.
The problem is not even one of ideology. In truth, few of our leaders really believe this stuff. Mr. Martin the choirboy from Cork did not become a climate crusading trans rights activist over night. It’s just, he can’t think of anything else to be.
For example: if you were an Irish politician and took your cues primarily from Irish social media, you might think that one of the major problems in Ireland is the cost of contraception for young women. And you might, then, in turn, devote a whole paragraph of your budget to delivering free contraception to young women. That, of course, is exactly what the Irish Government did, a week ago. We can safely say it won them no votes, or at least, none worth the trouble.
The reason for this is that whatever young women and young voters in general might say on social media, free contraception is not really the problem that they most want to see solved. Like every generation before them, they have aspirations: They want to be able to get married, or at least form a long term relationship. They want a job that allows them a comfortable life and a fulfilling career. They want a secure home. They might complain on social media about the cost of contraception, but in the big picture, it is not especially important to them.
This is a problem which sums up the challenge the Irish Government finds itself in. It keeps focusing on issues which do not really matter to the voters, in favour of issues which appear salient on social media, and are popular in the newspapers and with NGOs. Climate change, for example, has perennially been one of the least important issues to Irish voters. The Carbon Tax has perennially been unpopular. But this Government is convinced, primarily through the work of a small cohort of activists, that being seen to act on the climate will win it votes. It will not. And even those voters who do wish to see radical climate action will not vote for them – because there will always be someone on the opposition benches pledging to do more.
The Irish Government’s agenda, these days, is the agenda of the right-on online activist. Government departments now use gender neutral pronouns. Millions of euros flow to the fight against the hated far right. Every second word in a Minister’s speech must be “diversity” or “inclusion”.
In the meantime, for the millions of Irish voters who roll their eyes at that nonsense, there is not much on offer. They see prices rising at the pumps. They see crime rising in their streets. They see home ownership for their children become at best a dream. They see long waiting lists in hospitals. Many increasingly find it hard to get an appointment with their GP.
The extraordinary thing about the Irish Government at the moment is that not one of those issues could really be considered a priority for it. It is simply unable to articulate a vision on healthcare, for example, beyond incremental and endless spending increases, and something called Sláintecare which is meaningless to the average voter. It has no message whatever on crime. On housing, it exists to deliver “plans” – most of which involve huge promises to build “affordable housing” which will not materialise until well after the next election. On every issue which really matters, there is a sense of drift, and a hope that it might somehow get better on its own.
No, this Government’s real energies are devoted to the social media causes. Ending direct provision – an issue which matters to basically nobody. Climate action – ditto. Chairing the UN Security Council – yawn. Fighting with the UK over Brexit: People care, but the Government has managed to make them more angry with London than grateful to Dublin. Banning hate speech and protests at abortion clinics: In truth, outside of activists on both sides, nobody cares. To be in Government today is to be Simon Harris: Endlessly searching for the viral tiktok moment. Or twitter moment. Or facebook moment.
Consider as an alternative the main opposition party. One may like, or loathe them, but one cannot deny their focus: Health and Housing. Health and Housing. Did they mention, by any chance, health and housing?
Sinn Fein were attacked from the left this week for fudging their position on abortion in Northern Ireland. They do not care, in truth, what the social media left thinks. They have enough sense to know that those people will never express happiness and contentment. Instead they ignore it, and march on: Health and Housing. If Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil were attacked from the left on abortion, we’d have a full out campaign to remind voters about repeal. That’s the difference.
The problem for this Government is that it has no real ideas of its own. All of its thinking is outsourced for it to various lobby groups: Fine Gael TDs are eager to be photographed with the National Womens’ Council in a way no Sinn Fein TD ever really bothers with. And yet, none of those lobby groups will ever support them in return. An NGO can never, ever, say that its aims have been met, for if its aims are ever met, it will be redundant. If homelessness is ever solved, for example, what happens to our 15 homelessness charities, and all of those employed by them?
No, this Government has tied its political fortunes to those structurally incentivised to oppose it and call it a failure. It has forgotten what voters actually care about. It no longer legislates as much as it lectures on all those things that we mentioned in paragraph one.
They are in imminent danger of sickening people to the point of no return.