Credit: Gript

Emails reveal Donnelly was wrong to accuse Tóibín of lies on nursing home in chaos

Peadar Tóibín TD has called on the Minister for Health, Stephen Donnelly to make a statement in the Dáil to correct a statement he made in relation to a Covid-19 outbreak in a nursing home in Galway in October.

The Minister accused the Aontú leader of telling a “flat out lie” when he raised the issue of the disturbing case of the care home where a majority of staff and residents had tested positive for Covid-19 and had been left without assistance from the HSE.

Now the Meath West TD has obtained a number of documents under the Freedom of Information Act from the HSE regarding nursing homes – and he says the Minister must correct the Dáil record and acknowledge that the very real concerns of doctors and care workers which had been undermined by the Minister’s response.

“Under Freedom of Information I’ve now gotten my hands on an email which was sent to Minister Donnelly shortly before that particular Dáil debate. This email was from the office of the CEO of the HSE – Paul Reid – and it says; “the HSE has been trying to source staff to support the nursing home since Monday… despite contacting all agencies yesterday the HSE has been unable to source any agency nursing staff”.

“Given that the Minister received this email from the HSE in the early afternoon of the 22nd October, I am asking that he now make a statement before the Dáil and withdraw his remarks which questioned the veracity of this story”.

Deputy Tóibín said that the documents “paint a bleak picture of communication standards within the Health Service Executive”.

“On the 22nd October this year the Claire Byrne Show broke a story regarding a nursing home in Galway where the majority of staff and residents had tested positive for Covid-19 and had been left without any assistance from the HSE. I raised the matter in the Dáil that day to see if the government could ensure that this nursing home was offered assistance. In the middle of my contribution Minister Donnelly turned around and accused me of telling lies – “that’s a flat out lie” were his exact words”

“This statement from the Minister did not just call into question the credibility of me, but also the integrity of the Doctor who raised the concerns and the researchers and producers of the Claire Byrne Show,” he asserted.

 

“Under Freedom of Information I’ve now gotten my hands on an email which was sent to Minister Donnelly shortly before that particular Dáil debate. This email was from the office of the CEO of the HSE – Paul Reid – and it says; “the HSE has been trying to source staff to support the nursing home since Monday… despite contacting all agencies yesterday the HSE has been unable to source any agency nursing staff”. Given that the Minister received this email from the HSE in the early afternoon of the 22nd October, I am asking that he now make a statement before the Dáil and withdraw his remarks which questioned the veracity of this story”.

“There are serious questions to be asked when we look at these documents – there seems to be a massive breakdown of communication in the HSE when it comes to nursing homes. The first case of Covid 19 was detected in the Nightingale Nursing Home in Galway on 19th October. Over the ensuing days two staff members were left looking after all the residents and begged the HSE to help. When the Claire Byrne Show broke the story, when I raised it in the Dáil and the local GP began to tweet about it, only then did the hierarchy within the HSE become aware of the issue, some four days later. They began frantically sending links to the GP’s tweets among themselves. In one email Dr Daly in Ballygar is referenced, and an official in the HSE says “I think that’s in Galway”. An astonishing statement. If a nursing home say nearly all its patients have tested positive for this killer virus, surely the matter should have been brought straight to the top of the HSE!”

“The Minister for Older Persons, Mary Butler sent a very important letter to Mr Reid regarding the escalating situation in nursing homes on the 19th October. Astonishingly a full month elapsed before Mr Reid decided to write back to Minister Butler on November 16th. Now we’d understand if I sent a letter and didn’t get a response, but a government Minister should not be left waiting a month for a response to an urgent letter she sends to the HSE. Communication within the HSE needs serious improvement. It is clear that the HSE head quarters is not communicating effectively with their teams on the ground, with HIQA and even with the government. They need to urgently improve their communication channels. On a day of such a huge scandal in a nursing home, a grave situation, they only learned about it four days later through the opposition TDs, the media and tweets from a local doctor. Nursing homes need serious support from the HSE, and is disappointing that no lessons appear to have been learned from the first wave”, concluded Deputy Tóibín.

Share mdi-share-variant mdi-twitter mdi-facebook mdi-whatsapp mdi-telegram mdi-linkedin mdi-email mdi-printer mdi-chevron-left Prev Next mdi-chevron-right Related
Comments are open

The biggest problem Ireland faces right now is:

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...