On November 16, the European Council — with the sign-off of the Irish government — announced it was expanding its list of sanctioned individuals relating to Russia’s war in Ukraine.
Included in this updated list is Irish journalist Chay Bowes.
For most people on this island, Bowes needs little introduction. A co-founder of the controversial left-leaning news outlet The Ditch, which has regularly broken headline-making stories regarding government corruption since its establishment in 2021. Bowes has also regularly made himself a headache for government officials in his own right, being a key facilitator in the exposé of then-Taoiseach Leo Varadkar’s alleged leaking of sensitive government documents to outside private organisations.
In short, Bowes is — and will likely continue to be — a gadfly for Ireland’s governing classes. One that has proven his effectiveness time and time again. And one that has proven the value of his work to the general public, who have benefitted from his investigations into the activities of public officials, regardless of whether or not they agreed with the man’s personal politics.
Bowes is also a big fan of the Russian Federation. A regular fixture on state-controlled TV channel Russia Today, Bowes regularly hosts the show Moscow Mules on the network, and regularly takes to both legacy and social media outlets to defend the actions of the country’s government. He has been just as voracious in his criticisms of the Ukrainian government, NATO, and the European Union, placing a substantial amount of the blame for the current conflict on these latter two organisations.
Furthermore, he accuses many European leaders on both the left and right of being involved in a “conspiracy” against Moscow that is harming both Moscow and the EU.
“This conspiracy is that they hate Russia more than they love Europe,” he told one Russian publication during an interview last year.
“Confronting Russia is their only goal, not the well-being of their countries.”
Such views are not justified by the facts. While I am no fan of the current EU governing class, the idea that they are the ones responsible for Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is not based in reality.
Ultimately, it was Russian President Vladimir Putin who decided to march troops over the border into another sovereign country, a decision that everyone else — whether they be Ukrainian, Russian, or European — are all now paying for.
Bowes, on this issue and many others related to it, is in the wrong. But being wrong about something is not a crime. At least, it shouldn’t be.
Due to an edict signed off by the European Council, Bowes is banned from entering or transiting through the European Union. All of his bank accounts and holdings inside the bloc — including those located in his home country of Ireland — are frozen. According to a post made on social media, he was not made aware of the decision beforehand. According to EU rules on the matter, they may not have had to directly inform him of this decision at all.
The justification for such penalties — according to a very limited explanation released by the Council in the wake of the announcement — is that Bowes had been “involved in numerous information operations” run by sanctioned Kremlin-aligned entities, and that “he is also involved in the regular amplification of content produced by” a Moscow disinformation project.
“He is therefore implementing, supporting and facilitating actions or policies attributable to the Government of the Russian Federation which undermine or threaten democracy, the rule of law, stability or security in the Union,” they wrote.
No evidence was publicly provided for any of the claims made against Bowes, nor any explanation as to how each one in particular justifies the penalties levelled against him.
The Irish journalist does technically have a right to appeal the Council’s decision. However, the effectiveness of each route seems limited at best.
His first option is to write to the Council directly with arguments as to why he should not be on the sanctions list, though it is unclear how effective appealing in writing to the very people who have just punished you will be. He can also challenge the decision in the European courts. However, not only would such an approach likely be near cost-prohibitive, but it would also likely take in excess of two years before his case was heard, according to official information on case waiting times.
He could also seek an urgent hearing for the application of interim relief, potentially preventing or mitigating the sanctions he is facing from being actively applied before a formal court appeal is heard, but the success of such a move is by no means guaranteed.
It should at this point also be mentioned that no one, not even the European Council, is actually accusing Bowes of having committed any crimes. There is no provided evidence of any warrant for the journalist’s arrest, or even of any outstanding civil case regarding his statements on Ukraine. He is simply being sanctioned as a result of his activities in relation to a state that Europe, at least on paper, is not at war with.
This whole situation should send shivers down the spine of all decent citizens. Even if Bowes’ views on Ukraine are far from what I — any many others — would consider reasonable, the fact that EU leaders have seen fit to freeze his bank accounts and ban him from travelling through Europe over non-criminal speech is beyond the pale. The fact our government signed off on it, but appear to be trying to justify it in the media, is even more worrisome.
It should also be noted that this implementation of sanctions will do nothing for Ukraine’s war effort. Europe’s push to sanction Russia over the war has not been all that effective, especially when compared to Kyiv’s kinetic campaign against Moscow’s fossil fuel industry. The Brussels sanctions against individual journalists will achieve even less of an effect, meaning they represent a serious threat to free expression and journalistic freedom without any meaningful social or security benefit.
And the sanctions are most certainly not hurting Bowes’ reach. Just hours after posting a video on X discussing the sanctions, Bowes followed up by announcing that he had just breached 300,000 followers on the platform. Third-party social media monitoring software further cements the Streisand effect surrounding the journalist, showing a spike in his viewer and follower metrics right after the penalties landed. X itself is meanwhile swamped with people who both support and criticise Bowes, lambasting the EU for passing the sanctions.
In short, if anything, this seems to have been a major win for Russia, raising the profile of one of its strongest media supporters inside the European ecosystem while making Brussels itself look like an equivalent authoritarian regime.
With this in mind, there really is no justification for sanctioning Bowes. Not only is it an attack on a prominent journalist for what appears to be legal speech, it also represents a completely ineffective attempt at damaging the Kremlin that instead only seems to amplify its views on the Ukraine war.
But when has the self-defeating nature of a policy prevented Europe from pursuing it?
The Irish Department of Foreign Affairs was approached for comment and clarification regarding the topic of this article.