Sentencing Judge, Mr Justice Tony Hunt, has said that the case of Riad Bouchaker “properly belongs in the life sentence category.”
This morning at the Central Criminal Court in Dublin, Riad Bouchaker was given a life sentence for a knife attack on young children and the adults who tried to protect them. Mr Justice Tony Hunt described it as “an indiscriminate attack” on “particularly vulnerable children” who “posed no threat” to anyone.
Bouchaker was convicted of three counts of attempted murder, one of intentionally causing serious harm, three of assault causing harm and one knife offence. The court heard extensive medical and Garda evidence, as well as victim impact statements. The court took all counts into account in sentencing.
“Sudden, furious and sustained”
Mr Justice Hunt said Bouchaker had displayed “exceptional and deeply disturbing behaviour” and that “in less than half a minute”, armed with a large knife, he had unleashed the attack on the children. CCTV evidence, he said, showed its “sudden, furious and sustained” nature.
The judge said the children were exceptionally vulnerable and posed no threat of any kind, and that the weapon was one of considerable lethality. He said there was an “absolutely absent” connection between the victims and whatever minor complaint the accused had. He added that he would make no comment on how Bouchaker came to be at the scene, as he was unsure what inference should be drawn.
He said the intervention of others “at considerable personal risk prevented a bigger tragedy”.
Justice Hunt paid tribute to Leanne Flynn, who he said “reacted selflessly and fearlessly” and was “an example to everyone”. He said he hoped she could return to caring for children, but noted that due to injuries she sustained in the attack, including the loss of her spleen and her ongoing physical disability, he acknowledged that this was uncertain.
He said her actions undoubtedly protected the children that day.
He also praised members of the public who were “careless of their own safety” to ward off the attack, some of whom even tried to protect the accused for overzealous interventions in the immediate aftermath of the attack. They came, he said, “from all parts of the city and indeed all parts of the globe”. He thanked the emergency responders and Gardaí, particularly those who carried out the “difficult” and “fraught” task of interviewing the accused, and the jury, “for whom this must have been a particularly difficult case”.
“Permanently altered”
The most seriously injured child, a girl, suffered a stab wound to the chest that penetrated her heart, causing catastrophic brain injury. She is non-verbal and will never live independently. The judge said her life and her family had been permanently altered.
Turning to her mother’s victim impact statement, he said Bouchaker had frequently expressed relief that no one died, but the consequences for the girl and her family were “perhaps much worse”.
He said the accused had plunged them into “an unimaginable world of pain and torment”, and expressed the hope that the family would receive all the practical help and resources they need.
Turning to the other children, who were significantly less seriously injured, Mr Justice Hunt said it would be “wrong to assess the impact on the basis of physical harm alone”, as a “profound loss of the sense of safety”, which he said children were “entitled to” continues to be felt by the children, their families and others. The victim impact statements, he said, were “among the most moving that I have heard in my time”. He added that no sentence could undo the burden the parents now carry.
The court heard that Bouchaker has cognitive impairment and epilepsy. The judge accepted these conditions were relevant and had been properly argued, that his condition worsened after injuries he sustained, and that his current functioning is significantly impaired, and that for Bouchaker prison would be “worse than that of someone in ordinary health”.
However, Bouchaker was found fit to stand trial, and the jury rejected his account, he added.
Mr Justice Hunt said his difficulties were “entirely self-inflicted” and not comparable to “the devastation that directly followed from his sinister actions on that day.”
The defence team told the court this morning that Bouchaker had been in hospital, and details of his condition and prognosis were “largely unavailable” because of “data protection”. He has recently been returned to prison, his defending senior counsel said.
The judge said that whatever his immediate medical position, the offences were unprecedented and he could not reduce the sentence, adding: “this is an entirely self-created situation”.
“Narrow category”
Explaining his decision, Mr Justice Hunt said the case involved “multiple victims”, principally young children, and a lethal weapon, and was “not a single act directed at a single victim”. He said the combination of multiple attempted murders, the victims’ vulnerability and the “catastrophic and permanent injury inflicted on the young child” elevated it. Culpability and harm were “so far up the scale” that a consecutive regime would ordinarily apply, he said, and only a sentence at the very highest end was appropriate.
The purposes of sentencing, he said, were punishment, condemnation and public protection, alongside the need for general deterrence and to “unambiguously condemn attacks on vulnerable children”. He said extreme culpability and harm displaced the room for mitigation that might exist in less serious cases.
A life sentence was “both necessary and proportionate”, he said, and the case fell into a “narrow category” that warrants it. “This case properly belongs in the life sentence category,” he said.
“I ask the rhetorical question: If a life sentence is not imposed here, when would it ever be imposed in circumstances where the law provides for it?”
The sentences, to run concurrently, are life for the attempted murder of a then five-year-old girl who suffered catastrophic injuries, 20 years for causing serious harm to Leanne Flynn, 15 years each for the attempted murder of a boy and a girl, eight years for causing harm to a boy, seven years for causing harm to a girl, five years for causing harm to a young Frenchman, and four years for production of an article with intent to cause harm.