In a recent article in Gript, Cormac Lucey challenged one of the central assumptions behind Ireland’s growing disinformation industry: that ordinary citizens cannot distinguish truth from falsehood without the guidance of government-approved experts.
But there is a more fundamental question: why should we trust the government to decide what is true when its own record is so far from trustworthy?
In a democracy, citizens elect politicians, fund public institutions and expect those institutions to work for them. Yet we are increasingly told that misinformation is such a serious threat that the State must finance organisations to identify it, combat it and educate the public about what to believe.
Who gave these organisations the authority to determine which opinions are legitimate, which claims are dangerous and which citizens need correcting?
The temptation is hardly new. In the biblical story of Adam and Eve, the serpent promises that eating from the Tree of the Knowledge of Good and Evil will make humanity like God. The temptation is not merely to acquire knowledge, but to claim the authority to decide good and evil.
There is something remarkably similar about institutions appointing themselves guardians of public truth, particularly when the questions they seek to settle are political, ideological and deeply contested.
COIMISIÚN NA MÉAN
Ireland adopted a National Counter Disinformation Strategy in 2025. Budget 2026 allocated €1.1 million towards its implementation, including research, fact-checking and media literacy.
In May, Coimisiún na Meán awarded more than €268,000 to projects intended to tackle disinformation.
There is nothing wrong with teaching people to check sources or question dubious claims. The problem begins when public money is used to give selected organisations a privileged position in determining what the public should believe.
Who selects these experts? Who scrutinises their ideological assumptions? Who decides when a controversial opinion becomes misinformation? And, perhaps most importantly, what happens when the misinformation comes from the government itself?
Consider the government’s own record. We have a political establishment that struggles to answer what a woman is, yet apparently considers itself qualified to guide the public on truth and falsehood.
We have authorities that withhold information about the country of origin of people committing crimes, limiting what citizens are allowed to know. We have politicians who repeatedly claimed for months not to know about What’s the T?, a pro-trans book containing sexually explicit material that had been recommended to minors.
These are not minor matters. They concern transparency, public accountability and highly contested social policies. Yet the same political establishment wants us to trust its judgment about which narratives are misleading and which are acceptable.
And this is before considering the government’s competence in managing its existing responsibilities. The National Children’s Hospital, originally budgeted at €650 million in 2014, has reached an approved budget of €2.24 billion after years of delays, disputes and spiralling costs. In July, Sinn Féin TD John Brady reported that 98 electric buses worth €58.3 million remained unused because the necessary charging infrastructure was not ready.
Imagine a private company repeatedly wasting money on this scale. Its customers would leave, its investors would withdraw and bankruptcy could follow. In government, however, the taxpayer simply receives another bill.
A political establishment that struggles to build a hospital within budget, coordinate buses with charging stations or provide clear answers about its own policies now expects to be trusted as an arbiter of public truth. Why?
DOUBLE STANDARD
There is also a remarkable double standard in the way misinformation is treated. Politicians routinely make promises about housing, hospital waiting lists, taxation and public spending that turn out to be wildly unrealistic. Yet when these promises collapse, they are treated as ordinary political disappointments.
Meanwhile, an ordinary citizen sharing a questionable statistic about immigration, climate policy or public expenditure can find himself accused of spreading misinformation, promoting harmful narratives or contributing to extremism.
Consider the absurdity of this arrangement. If you buy something on Amazon and the product does not match its description, you are entitled to return it and receive your money back. That is basic consumer protection. But when a politician wins your vote by making promises that turn out to be false, there is no refund, no equivalent protection and apparently not even misinformation. Indeed, according to Media Minister Patrick O’Donovan, broken election promises do not constitute misinformation.
Of course, a broken promise is not necessarily a deliberate lie. Circumstances can change. But governments make factual claims, present projections, select statistics and promote narratives to justify their policies. Why should these claims escape the same rigorous scrutiny demanded of ordinary citizens?
If misinformation is genuinely the concern, surely the statements of those exercising political power should be examined more closely, not less.
This exposes a fundamental conflict of interest. The government is not a neutral observer of public debate. It is a participant with policies to defend, mistakes to conceal and reputations to protect. Even when fact-checking organisations are formally independent, public funding raises legitimate questions.
Will organisations financed by the State investigate misleading claims made by the departments funding them? Will they challenge the ideological assumptions behind the programmes they have been commissioned to deliver? Or will their scrutiny fall disproportionately on those challenging the prevailing political consensus?
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? Who watches the watchmen? The same questions must be asked of academics and publicly funded organisations that present themselves as experts in misinformation, extremism and acceptable speech.
TOM FELLE
A particularly revealing example emerged on 6 November, when RTÉ Prime Time reported that Tom Felle, an associate professor of journalism at the University of Galway and an expert on fake news, had claimed a doctorate from City St George’s, University of London, that he had not been awarded. RTÉ reported that the university confirmed no journalism doctorate had been awarded through the route Felle claimed during the relevant academic years. He had also been referred to as “Dr Felle” in university publications and material submitted to the Oireachtas.
In 2024, Felle had been appointed an expert assessor for Coimisiún na Meán.
The irony is difficult to miss. Someone whose professional work concerned trust, transparency and the verification of information was himself the subject of serious questions about the accuracy of his academic credentials.
In a 2024 article for The Journal, Felle criticised what he described as “baseless far-right narratives” about immigration and called on politicians and the media to confront misleading claims. Yet the allegations surrounding his own credentials demonstrate why academic titles, institutional positions and expert appointments should never be treated as substitutes for evidence. Those who demand scrutiny of everyone else’s claims must be prepared to face precisely the same scrutiny themselves.
GOVT FUNDING FOR SOME NARRATIVES
This raises a broader question about the intellectual and ideological foundations of the disinformation industry. The government gives funding to NGOs, media, and academic projects to create concepts and make them mainstream. Some of those concepts are toxic masculinity, the manosphere, institutional racism, white privilege, hate speech or the far right. Then use them as a simple explanation for everything that goes wrong in society. Not that those realities do not exist, but the government has the capacity to fund projects or media that align with that narrative and ignore the ones that don’t.
Why only fund one particular viewpoint of the world as if this was the only truth? These are politically charged subjects in which the distinction between objective evidence, moral judgment and ideological assumptions can become dangerously blurred.
Take the term “far right”. Does it refer specifically to authoritarianism, racial supremacy and extremist political movements? Or can it also be applied to ordinary citizens who oppose current immigration policies, question certain equality initiatives or hold socially conservative views?
Who determines the boundary? Is there even a debate? And how can we be confident that academics and NGOs, operating within institutions often characterised by a narrow range of political assumptions, will apply these labels consistently?
We do not need to look far to see the danger. In the UK, one report put the number of arrests for communications offences at more than 60,000 over recent years, many involving social media posts. Is this really the direction Ireland wants to follow?
Apparently in Ireland, politicians can make promises that never materialise without being accused of misinformation, while media organisations can face potential fines of up to €20 million under the regulatory framework governing harmful content. The imbalance should concern anyone who values freedom of expression.
A democracy cannot function properly if those in power acquire an increasingly privileged role in determining which criticisms are legitimate and which are dangerous. Nor should freedom of expression depend on whether the government, an academic committee or a publicly funded NGO approves of a particular opinion.
DEEPLY PATRONISING
Underlying this entire industry is a deeply patronising assumption: that Irish citizens are incapable of navigating political disagreement without an officially supported network of experts telling them which views deserve credibility.
Adults should be capable of hearing competing arguments, examining evidence and reaching their own conclusions. Sometimes those conclusions will be unpopular with politicians, academics, journalists or NGOs. That is not a defect of democracy. It is democracy. The solution is to teach citizens skills in critical thinking and debate, not to treat them like children.
Ireland has urgent problems in housing, healthcare, transport and the management of public money. Instead of concentrating on these responsibilities, the State is helping to finance an industry that risks treating disagreement with approved narratives as evidence of ignorance, manipulation or extremism. Far from strengthening public trust, such an approach risks destroying what remains of it.
The government has a duty to tell the truth, not the authority to decide it. It has an obligation to inform citizens, not to instruct them what to believe. And it has no special entitlement to public trust merely because it holds political power. In a democracy – from the Greek dēmos “people” and kratos “power”, meaning “rule by the people” – the people are supposed to hold the government accountable, not the other way around.