The Government has been accused of rushing to dismantle Ireland’s Triple Lock in order to involve the country in a European army, during a heated debate in the Dáil.
Opposition TDs last njght raised concerns over the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026, which proposes removing the requirement for United Nations authorisation before more than 12 members of the Defence Forces can be deployed overseas.
The Government has rejected suggestions that the proposed changes would compromise Irish neutrality or lead to Ireland joining a military alliance.
‘GOVT PROCEEDING AT HASTE TO GET INVOLVED IN EUROPEAN ARMY’
The Dáil heard last night that its removal would amount to a “betrayal”.
It was also claimed that the Government “seems to be proceeding at haste to get involved in a European army”.
The Government wants the legislation passed before the end of 2026, however, it is understood that around 20 Fianna Fáil TDs and senators have expressed concerns about the legislation.
Under the existing arrangement, the deployment of more than 12 Defence Forces personnel overseas requires three approvals: Government approval, Dáil approval, and United Nations Security Council authorisation.
The proposed legislation, the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026, would remove the third requirement, leaving Government and Dáil approval in place. would remove the third requirement, leaving Government and Dáil approval in place.
It was reported on Wednesday that Fianna Fáil’s Wille O’Dea has proposed amendment could provide a compromise, but Fine Gael is understood to be reluctant to support it.
Former Defence Minister Willie O’Dea, in a challenge to the Government, is proposing amendments to retain a link to UN approval.
O’Dea wants overseas deployments to be consistent with a current UN General Assembly resolution, with ministers required to explain how a proposed mission complies with it.
On Tuesday, Sinn Féin brought forward a motion calling for a referendum to protect Irish neutrality and retain the Triple Lock.
‘UNSEEMLY AND INDECENT HASTE’
The Government’s argument is that it can amend the legislation through the Oireachtas without holding a constitutional referendum.
A number of TDs joined calls for a referendum to be held, including Independent TDs Brian Stanley and Carol Nolan.
Nolan told the Dáil that Ireland should not weaken its existing safeguards simply because Europe faces changing security challenges.
The Offaly TD said constituents had contacted her urging her to vote against the Bill as she criticised a lack of public consultation.
“There is unseemly and indecent haste in what the Government is doing in bypassing certain stages of the legislative scrutiny of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026,” said Nolan.
“People are pleading to have their say, for fairness and justice and for the matter to be put before them in a referendum.”
“It is shameful to have this proposal before us and to see that an Taoiseach, Deputy Micheál Martin, is not listening to Irish people,” added the Deputy.
Independent TD Brian Stanley also strongly criticised the proposed legislation, describing it as the biggest change in Irish foreign policy and military alignment in 70 years.
GOVT BEING “LESS THAN HONEST”
Stanley accused the Government of being “less than honest” about the purpose of the Defence (Amendment) Bill 2026, arguing that it would move Ireland away from traditional UN-approved peacekeeping missions towards operations involving what the legislation describes as “relevant international forces”.
He questioned what the proposed concept of “peace enforcement” would mean for Irish troops, claiming it could involve active military engagement in international conflicts.
“To do so without a referendum is a betrayal of the Irish people,” said Stanley.
“It means active combat, and the Government should clearly state that.”
Independent Ireland leader Michael Collins said TDs were debating an issue “that Fianna Fáil would at one time have stood on a different side of the fence on but it has now jumped ship.”
“We would like to know why and get to the real reason,” added Collins.
“The Irish people are perfectly capable of deciding major questions about their country’s future,” added the Cork TD.
“If Ministers are so confident that this is the right course for Ireland, why are they afraid to put the question before the people in a referendum?” he asked.
Collins cited an online poll conducted by Independent Ireland which received 45,000 responses, claiming that 96.7% of participants supported holding a referendum before the Triple Lock was changed.
Other Independent TDs took a different stance – including Michael Healy-Rae, who defended the Government legislation.
He argued that retaining requirements in their current form was “certainly not the right thing to do”.
‘MISINFORMATION’ AROUND PROPOSALS
Healy-Rae said Ireland’s ability to participate in overseas peacekeeping missions had been restricted since 2014 because it was “beholden to others” and required UN Security Council authorisation to deploy more than 12 personnel overseas.
Healy-Rae said he had listened to the views of serving and retired Defence Forces personnel, including those who had participated in peacekeeping missions, and argued that they did not want the existing arrangements retained.
He further said “misinformation” existed surrounding proposals.
He said some contributions amounted to “trying to give people the impression this is sending our people to war and being part of greater armies” which he described as “a load of nonsense.”
However, his brother, Deputy Danny Healy-Rae, said he believed that “the Government seems to be proceeding at haste to get involved in a European army.”
“While we gave money for humanitarian reasons to the Ukrainian people who came here, I and many others do not think it is right to give money to Ukraine to keep the war going,” said the Kerry politician.
“We are on one side then. We should remain neutral. A lot of money was given to Zelenskyy again in the past week, and he was smiling at the Taoiseach on the television, which is no wonder when he was given €25 million.
“While we are glad to hear today that construction is getting €20 million for green diesel, the industry paid a lot of money into that already because it has paid a lot of tax toward that €20 million. People have been waiting for it since last April or May,” he added.
Independent TD Mattie McGrath accused Taoiseach Micheál Martin of abandoning Fianna Fáil’s traditional principles over the proposed changes to the Triple Lock, describing the party’s position as a “total sell-out”.
McGrath, a former Fianna Fáil member whose late father was a founding member of the party, accused the Government of prioritising power and European political positions over its previous commitments.
“It is power at any price and jobs in Europe at any price,” he said.
“Now, we see it has further sold out its policies. That is all it is; a total sell-out,” added McGrath.
“Why is the Government so afraid of the people?”
On Micheál Martin, McGrath said: “He will sign up to anything his EU masters want.”