I watched Ben Scallan’s exchange with Education Minister Hildegarde Naughton last week with interest, when he questioned her about the teaching of white privilege in Irish schools.
The Minister’s response was to plead ignorance and demand respect, as though questioning what is being put before our children is itself inappropriate. It is a familiar routine: challenge the prevailing ideology and you are met with offended indignation and lectures about respect and kindness, but never an answer.
The Minister also referenced her new survey, Perspectives on Bullying Behaviour, which is asking children about ‘diverse sexual orientations and/or gender identities’. She has not published the questionnaire, which has been sent to schools for use with our children.
I am quite sure the Minister knows that white privilege is explicitly addressed in numerous resources. One place she could have referenced is the primary teaching resources for Bí Cineálta , a policy she herself lauded during the exchange.
In fact, Bí Cineálta has become a vehicle for introducing ideological content into schools, from gender and trans ideology to white privilege, and targeting what is described as ‘the dominant culture’. Ministers plead that this material is not on the curriculum while it is introduced through policies and their accompanying resources. So where is it in Bí Cineálta?
The Yellow Flag Programme was developed by the Irish Traveller Movement in 2008, initially inspired by the need to address discrimination experienced by Travellers in education. Travellers are a recognised ethnic minority with a distinct culture and traditions, and the community has traditionally been overwhelmingly Catholic – and white.
The programme was developed as a whole-school intercultural education model. It is difficult to believe that this was ever intended to become a vehicle for introducing white privilege, gender ideology and other contested beliefs into primary schools. But this is exactly how contested material finds its way into our schools: under the cover of something else.
The goodwill attached to the original initiative provides cover for material that many parents would neither expect nor accept in primary schools.
The Yellow Flag Programme’s glossary defines white privilege as:
“An institutional (rather than personal) set of benefits granted to those of us who, by ethnicity, resemble the people who dominate the powerful positions in our institutions.”
It goes on to describe the advantages afforded to white settled people, identifying them as the dominant cultural group with greater power to set cultural norms in Ireland.
This is not the only example of white privilege being introduced in our schools and we have a Minister who has perfected her ‘I know nothing’ routine.
The programme’s expansion into gender and sexual identity is equally clear. The Yellow Flag website contains eight videos corresponding to its eight steps.
In Video 7, Education in the Classroom, one child says:
“My favourite part was learning about genders because I like learning about each gender and… how to express what gender you are and that there are so many ways to be a boy and so many ways to be a girl.”
In Video 8, Diversity Code & Policy Review, another child explains:
“Our diversity code is respect all religions, respect all races, respect what gender you are, if you are gender fluid, if you’re transgender, if you’re bisexual… we accept everything.”
These primary school children have clearly been taught gender ideology in some detail. The Yellow Flag Programme is a long way from its original concept now.
The Yellow Flag National Coordinator explains how Step 8 involves examining the school’s own practices:
“In Step 8, along with the diversity code, we are really looking at that governance piece and interrogating the practices of the school institution. Is it possible that the school is unintentionally reinforcing the dominant culture through some protocols, or is it possible that we could introduce mechanisms that ensure that an anti-racist lens is taken across all areas of the school?”
In an Irish primary school, it is difficult to see what ‘the dominant culture’ could refer to other than Irish culture. Is Irish culture now viewed in our schools through this “anti-racist lens”? What definition of racism are teachers being trained to teach? Are children being taught that Irish culture is inherently racist?
She continues:
“By embedding anti-racism in the very policies and practices that govern the school institution, you’re ensuring that your commitment to this work continues year after year, long after the Yellow Flag has been awarded.”
Under Step 8, the programme references a “civil society based racist reporting system”. The system collects reports of racist incidents, with the data feeding into quarterly and annual reports, public information, lobbying submissions and a wider national conversation on racism.
The programme offers no evidence that racism occurs in our primary schools on a scale warranting an initiative of this breadth. It is a “build it and they will come” approach: teach children to identify racism in ordinary interactions and they will begin interpreting those interactions through that lens, turning previously insignificant differences between friends into something to examine, classify and report. One result is likely an increase in reported incidents of racism by design.
At the end of the programme, a Yellow Flag is raised in celebration of the school’s supposed achievement in tackling racism, even where there was no evidence of a problem to begin with.
Embedding these policies and practices across entire schools to impose contested ideas is institutional ideological capture.
What is described in these videos is activism, not education.
Dr Niamh Regan is a scientist and career coach based in County Meath. She has a PhD in Chemistry from National University of Ireland, Galway and completed postdoctoral research at the University of Limerick in the Materials and Surfaces Science Institute. She later completed a Postgraduate Diploma in Education, followed by a diploma in Web Applications, and has worked in teaching, lecturing and educational development roles.
She currently runs her own career coaching practice and engages with education from the perspective of a concerned parent. She maintains a strong interest in curriculum, policy and wider developments in the sector. Dr Regan is a mother of one primary school–aged child.
Niamh Regan has written about the Bí Cineálta Programme here.