A Dublin councillor has demanded a full investigation into the spending on Merrion Square’s controversial new tearooms, after new figures revealed that €4.67 million has already been spent on the long-delayed development.
Independent councillor Gavin Pepper said almost 97 per cent of the expenditure had gone to just two companies, with building contractor Bracegrade receiving €3.81 million and architectural firm Bucholz McEvoy receiving €717,878.
The figures come amid mounting scrutiny of the project, which has been plagued by construction delays, escalating costs and questions over procurement procedures.
Dublin City Council initially projected that the development would cost approximately €3.4 million.
However, that estimate has more than doubled amid construction delays and additional consultancy expenses.
The tearooms were supposed to open last Spring, but remain under construction, having been dogged by controversy over mounting costs and delays.
“I am calling on DCC to publish the full cost breakdown, contract variations, approval records and response to the procurement failures,” said the Fingal / Ballymun councillor.
“Dubliners deserve a clear account of what they are paying for, and when it will finally be delivered,” said Cllr Pepper on Friday.
On November 2, the council announced an external review into the controversy-hit project’s escalating costs, delays and governance arrangements, while the proposed ten-year café lease has been suspended.
The most recent completion estimate stands at approximately €6.6 million, while the approved budget is €7.5 million.
The Local Government Audit Service previously identified procurement irregularities relating to increases in the architectural consultancy contract, which rose from €246,000 to €655,000.
Dublin City Council acknowledged that the increase did not comply fully with council, national and EU procurement regulations.
The project has also faced criticism over its prolonged construction timeline, with the council now forecasting that the facility will be operational in March 2027.
Cllr Pepper questioned how much was actually saved through a 2020 cost-cutting redesign, which reduced the building’s footprint and moved the public toilets inside the café.
“What did that exercise actually save? Who authorised the contract increases? What will the final bill be?” asked Cllr Pepper.
“Meanwhile, the proposed ten-year café lease would bring in €100,000 a year,” he added.
He is also seeking answers over who authorised increases to the contracts and what the final cost to taxpayers will be.
The controversy intensified earlier this month when the proposed ten-year café lease, which would generate €100,000 annually for the council, was suspended pending further consideration.
Cllr Pepper is calling on the council to publish a comprehensive breakdown of expenditure, contract variations, approval records and its response to the procurement failures.
In February 2026, councillors in the South-East Area Committee requested that representatives from the council’s Parks and Finance departments attend a meeting to provide a financial briefing on the project.
In response to councillors, Dublin City Council defended the development, saying the project originated in a 2014 conservation and management plan which identified a need for tearooms and public toilets in Merrion Square.
The council said the escalating costs were down to construction inflation, delays, additional design work, statutory requirements and an 18-month contractual dispute.
It has maintained that the project was overseen through its established capital-project governance procedures, although its own audit response acknowledged that increases to the architectural consultancy contract did not comply with procurement regulations.
The council has announced an external review of the project’s costs, delays and governance, with findings expected in February 2027.