Book Offer
This will close in 10 seconds
Peadar Toibín has said Ireland’s citizenship threshold has been “too low”, while Aontú TD Paul Lawless said it was “incredible” that someone could live in the country for decades without integrating into society following the conviction of Riad Bouchaker in the Parnell Square stabbing case.
Speaking to Gript on the Leinster House plinth this week after Bouchaker was convicted on all eight counts arising from the 2023 Parnell Square stabbing of 3 young children and an adult care worker, the Aontú leader and the party’s Mayo TD argued that the case should prompt a broader discussion around Irish citizenship, integration and migration policy.
Asked for his reaction to the verdict, Toibín said he was relieved that the case was reaching “some form of conclusion”, while expressing sympathy for the child who was most seriously injured in the attack and her family.
“It is obviously one of the most horrendous cases that has come before the State in my living memory,” he said.
“Our thoughts are with obviously that child whose whole future has been radically changed as a result of that heinous attack and our thoughts are with that child’s parents who in many way have been robbed of the child that was born to them.”
He also argued that Ireland needed stricter sentencing and said the State should make greater use of existing powers to remove people involved in criminal activity.
The discussion then turned to Irish citizenship after Gript asked whether the fact that Bouchaker had lived in Ireland for around 25 years before acquiring citizenship raised broader questions about the standards required for naturalisation.
Bouchaker has no known work history in Ireland and was on social welfare for years – it was a social welfare dispute that caused him to go on his rampage. He also had a poor grasp of the English language despite living in the country for 25 years, to the extent that he required a French Arabic interpreter in court and his Garda interview. Moreover, he described Ireland as a “shit” country, even going so far as to say in court ‘Your country is shit’.
Reacting to all this, Toibín said Aontú had long advocated what he described as one of the strictest migration policies in the Dáil, while maintaining that Ireland should continue to provide protection to people fleeing war and violence.
He said the party had consistently argued for tighter immigration controls, changes to asylum policy and measures aimed at reducing what he described as “pull factors” linked to housing and social welfare.
Asked directly whether the threshold for Irish citizenship should be higher, Toibín said he believed current standards were insufficient and argued that applicants should demonstrate greater integration into Irish society.
“I think that the citizenship bar has been too low in this country,” he said.
“There has been citizenship in my understanding that has been delivered to individuals less than five years in relation to asylum. I think that’s too low, at the very minimum it should be a five-year asylum process.
“And I do think that there is an onus on those seeking citizenship to make sure that they go into a position where they can assimilate into the local population in terms of language, in terms of culture and in terms of behaviour as well.
“We do want a situation where we have an integrated society. We don’t want a system where we have individuals who because of language or cultural attributes for example are not integrated into the mainstream of Irish society.”
Lawless also argued that the case highlighted broader questions about integration and citizenship, saying applicants should bear responsibility for becoming part of Irish society.
“Yeah I think it’s incredible that a person can be living here 20 or 30 years living on social welfare and not be integrated into society, not speak the language,” he said.
“And it does ask questions about how community employment schemes and activation schemes are working.”
The Mayo TD said the issue required a wider national conversation on citizenship and integration.
“So we do need a conversation about this and we do need a broader discussion on citizenship,” Lawless said.
“And the onus should be on the individual for any person coming to this country seeking citizenship I think it should be the onus on that person to actually integrate, to speak the language and integrate into society.”
Bouchaker was convicted last week on all eight charges relating to the stabbing attack outside Gaelscoil Choláiste Mhuire on Parnell Square East in Dublin in November 2023. The attack left a young girl with catastrophic injuries and also badly injured an adult school care assistant who heroically tried to intervene. Two other children were also injured, though less seriously.
This will close in 10 seconds